本文集中讨论心灵哲学中几个最有影响的反物理主义论证。对于每个论证,我都先给出原作者著作中关键段落的译文,然后对其进行简要的评注———主要是分析解释原作者工作的意义和影响,这个论证面临的主要反对意见,以及它向我们提出的尚未得到解答的哲学难题和挑战。 This article focuses on several of the most influential anti-physical arguments in spiritual philosophy. For each argument, I first give a translation of the key paragraphs of the original author’s writings and then give a brief commentary on them - primarily to analyze and explain the meaning and impact of the original author’s work, the main objections to this argument, and It presents us with unanswered philosophical puzzles and challenges.