刘心武的所谓“秦学”研究,看作一种“戏说”、“大话”的文学创作则可,看作学术则是错误的。刘心武的“揭秘红楼”实质上是以小说创作中“想象”、“虚构”的做法来搞学术。他所索隐的历史也是以小说的笔法“创造”的历史。他在《百家讲坛》的成功是一种商业上的成功,对艺术作品《红楼梦》的普及性作用也是危害极大的。 Liu Xinwu’s so-called “Qin study” is regarded as a kind of literary creation of “opera” and “lying”, but it is wrong to regard it as academic. Liu Xinwu’s “Secret Red Mansion” is essentially based on the novel’s “imagination” and “fictionalization” practices. The history he hides is also the history of “creation” in the novel style. His success in the “100 forums” is a kind of commercial success. It is also extremely detrimental to the popularization of the work “A Dream of Red Mansions”.