明代中期的《真赏斋帖》,因底本精良,摹勒精工,被誉为有明刻帖第一,在中国书法史上具有十分重要的地位。然而,对于这样重要的一部名帖,其钩摹者究竟是谁,长期以来竟一直未被厘清。清代以来,绝大部分研究者认为《真赏斋帖》的钩摹者为文徵明父子,这一观点几成定论,其影响一直持续到当代。今人施安昌对此提出疑义,但因论述不到位,缺 In the middle of the Ming Dynasty, “Really appreciate Zaitie” was honored as the first engraved plaque due to its excellent base and excellent quality. It has a very important position in the history of Chinese calligraphy. However, for such an important piece of celebrity post, who exactly is its name has not been clarified for a long time. Since the Qing Dynasty, the vast majority of researchers think that the “true reward” of the copy is Wen Zhengming father and son, this view is almost a conclusion, the impact has lasted until the present. An Anchang today raised doubt on this, but the discussion is not in place, missing