蜀汉政权核心人物诸葛亮多被褒评为贤相。然近年来,有些学者纷纷对此提出质疑。本文试图以蜀汉方面的荆州之败为例,从这一事件的细枝末节着眼再次审视诸葛亮这一历史人物,以求帮助后人对其做出更加公允的评判。 Zhuge Liang, the central figure of the Shu Han regime, was praised as a virtuous man. However, in recent years, some scholars have questioned this. This article attempts to Shuhan Han Jingzhou defeat, for example, from the minutiae of this incident to re-examine this historical figure Zhuge Liang, in order to help future generations to make a more fair judge.