让与担保性质学说虽然众多,但担保性质更加突出,故实际上是担保制度的一种。让与担保制度在德、日等国家的顺利采用有其条件,其为解决动产抵押的欠缺而生,但也有利有弊。在我国担保法律制度的现状下,没有必要引入让与担保制度。 Although the doctrine of transfer and guarantee is numerous, the nature of guarantee is more prominent, so it is actually a kind of guarantee system. With the guarantee system in Germany, Japan and other countries have the conditions for the smooth adoption, which is to solve the lack of chattel mortgage born, but there are pros and cons. Under the status quo of the legal system of guarantee in our country, it is not necessary to introduce the transfer guarantee system.