Inter-and intra-observer variability for the assessment of coronary artery tree description and lesi

来源 :中华医学杂志英文版 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:osinfobyl
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Background::Previously, we developed a novel n Coronary n Artery n Tree description and n Lesion n Evaluan Tion (CatLetn ?) angiographic scoring system, which was capable of accounting for the variability in the coronary anatomy and assisting in the risk-stratification of patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI). Our preliminary study revealed that the CatLet score better predicted clinical outcomes for AMI patients than the Synergy between Percutaneous Coronary Intervention with Taxus and Cardiac Surgery score. However, the reproducibility of the CatLet score in both inter-and intra-observer remains to be evaluated.n Methods::A total of 30 consecutive AMI patients, admitted in September of 2015, were independently assessed by two experienced interventional cardiologists to evaluate the inter-observer reproducibility of the CatLet score. Another set of 49 consecutive AMI patients, admitted between September and October in 2014, were assessed by one of the two interventional cardiologists on two occasions 3 months apart to evaluate the intra-observer reproducibility of the CatLet score. The weighted kappa was used to express the degree of agreement.Results::The weighted kappa values (95% confidence interval) for the intra- and inter-observer reproducibility of the CatLet Score were 0.82 (0.59-1.00, n Z= 7.23, n P < 0.001) and 0.86 (0.54-1.00, n Z= 5.20, n P 22). Regarding the adverse characteristics pertinent to lesions and dominance parameters, the kappa values for the inter-observer variability were 0.80 (0.56-1.00, n Z = 6.47, n P < 0.001) for total number of lesions, 0.57 (0.28-0.85, n Z = 3.03, n P < 0.001) for bifurcation, 0.69 (0.43-0.96, n Z = 5.06, n P < 0.001) for heavy calcification, 1.00 (0.72-1.00, n Z= 6.93, n P < 0.001) for tortuosity, 0.54 (0.26-0.82, n Z = 3.78, n P < 0.001) for thrombus, 0.69 (0.48-0.91, n Z = 6.29, n P < 0.001) for right coronary artery dominance, 0.69 (0.41-0.96, n Z = 4.91, n P < 0.001) for left anterior descending artery length, and 0.22 (0.06-0.51, n Z = 1.56, n P = 0.06) for diagonal size. Equivalent values for the intra-observer variability were moderate to almost perfect (range 0.54-1.00).n Conclusions::The reproducibility of the CatLet angiographic scoring system for evaluation of the coronary angiograms ranged from substantial to excellent. The high reproducibility of the CatLet angiographic scoring system will boost its clinical application to patients with AMI.“,”Background::Previously, we developed a novel n Coronary n Artery n Tree description and n Lesion n Evaluan Tion (CatLetn ?) angiographic scoring system, which was capable of accounting for the variability in the coronary anatomy and assisting in the risk-stratification of patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI). Our preliminary study revealed that the CatLet score better predicted clinical outcomes for AMI patients than the Synergy between Percutaneous Coronary Intervention with Taxus and Cardiac Surgery score. However, the reproducibility of the CatLet score in both inter-and intra-observer remains to be evaluated.n Methods::A total of 30 consecutive AMI patients, admitted in September of 2015, were independently assessed by two experienced interventional cardiologists to evaluate the inter-observer reproducibility of the CatLet score. Another set of 49 consecutive AMI patients, admitted between September and October in 2014, were assessed by one of the two interventional cardiologists on two occasions 3 months apart to evaluate the intra-observer reproducibility of the CatLet score. The weighted kappa was used to express the degree of agreement.Results::The weighted kappa values (95% confidence interval) for the intra- and inter-observer reproducibility of the CatLet Score were 0.82 (0.59-1.00, n Z= 7.23, n P < 0.001) and 0.86 (0.54-1.00, n Z= 5.20, n P 22). Regarding the adverse characteristics pertinent to lesions and dominance parameters, the kappa values for the inter-observer variability were 0.80 (0.56-1.00, n Z = 6.47, n P < 0.001) for total number of lesions, 0.57 (0.28-0.85, n Z = 3.03, n P < 0.001) for bifurcation, 0.69 (0.43-0.96, n Z = 5.06, n P < 0.001) for heavy calcification, 1.00 (0.72-1.00, n Z= 6.93, n P < 0.001) for tortuosity, 0.54 (0.26-0.82, n Z = 3.78, n P < 0.001) for thrombus, 0.69 (0.48-0.91, n Z = 6.29, n P < 0.001) for right coronary artery dominance, 0.69 (0.41-0.96, n Z = 4.91, n P < 0.001) for left anterior descending artery length, and 0.22 (0.06-0.51, n Z = 1.56, n P = 0.06) for diagonal size. Equivalent values for the intra-observer variability were moderate to almost perfect (range 0.54-1.00).n Conclusions::The reproducibility of the CatLet angiographic scoring system for evaluation of the coronary angiograms ranged from substantial to excellent. The high reproducibility of the CatLet angiographic scoring system will boost its clinical application to patients with AMI.
其他文献
随着近两年上海房地产的火爆发展,二手房买卖租赁的市场也水涨船高,经营得红红火火。一大批房产中介公司的店面一时间占据了各街头的显赫位置,如蓝色的信义、绿色的金丰易居
多年以后,雷坛坛像一个行者在北京四处出没,活跃无比,他准会想起那些遥远而亲切的味道。在微熹的早晨,空气中飘洒着淡淡的香味,那是稀粥的大米清香。夏日路边切开的半块西瓜,
本文是对地方文化资源的美术课程转化的一种思考.认为当地文化资源的开发,应是建立在当地整体地方文化这一基础之上的.充分利用具体物质形象的过程中,结合当地的其他地方文化
中华文化博大精深,是人类智慧的结晶,中国传统美术教育也有其独特性.鸦片战争后,中国大都采用外国美术教育的形态,既泯灭了传统的特色,又未真正借鉴国外的精髓.而今,针对全球
特纳综合征是较常见的性染色体异常疾病。本文报道了1例罕见性染色体数目和结构异常的特纳综合征,并利用荧光原位杂交(FISH)、全基因组低深度测序(CNV-seq)等遗传学技术明确了
长期以来人们对德育价值的认识一直有失偏颇,致使德育的理论建构和实践模式都很难有所突破。该论文从当代德育的内容、目标、主体和方法上对德育价值定位偏颇的现实表现进行
黑河发源于河南省漯河市东部,其中流经河南省上蔡县10个乡镇。该河接纳漯河市大部分工业废水和生活污水,河水呈棕黑色,距河数百米即可闻及恶臭,据环保部门监测:河水中的酚及
从理论分析和世界课程改革的趋势看,课程统整是一个大的趋势,这是由当今科学发展的特点、社会发展对新型人才的需要和教育的任务决定的.综合课程是学校本位的模式,是统整的课
本论文依据美国课程理论学者泰勒、布鲁姆和派纳等人的理论,将北京的明代法海寺壁画作为教学资源转换为课程设计,开发出美学文本课程.美学文本课程目标在于提高学生的审美能
本文结合我国儿童美术教育的现状,指出城市与城镇儿童美术教育的核心点应在国家教育宗旨基础上调动本土文化传统和文化资源,结合儿童身心发展,并为民族文化多样性更持久的传承,建