看实践山东:规范行政处罚裁量权近年来,山东省各级工商机关在规范行政处罚自由裁量权方面做了一些有益探索,取得明显成效。2014年全省系统共查处行政处罚案件7.66万件,申请听证案件26件,仅占属听证范围案件的0.05%,发生行政应诉案件42件,判决维持率大幅上升85.71%。在全省政风行风评议活动中,工商系统连续9年名列行政执法部门前三名,省 See Practice Shandong: Standardizing the Discretionary Power of Administrative Punishment In recent years, the industrial and commercial authorities at all levels in Shandong Province have made some useful explorations in standardizing the discretion of administrative punishment and have achieved remarkable results. In 2014, a total of 76,600 cases of administrative penalties were investigated and dealt with in the province’s system. There were 26 hearing cases, accounting for only 0.05% of the cases in the hearing range and 42 cases of administrative litigation. The judgment maintenance rate rose sharply by 85.71%. In the province’s popular style assessment activities, the business system for the 9th consecutive year ranked the top three administrative law enforcement departments, the provincial