论文部分内容阅读
中国政法大学刑法学教授、原中国法学会刑法研究会副会长阮齐林:《最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理利用信息网络实施诽谤等刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释》以“转发500次”界定“情节严重”是为制定一个定罪的可操作性条款。它是一个法律技术问题,不能说发一个帖子就定罪,对有侵害的行为追究的法律效果是多层次的,通过一个标准进行筛选,什么样的属于当事人之间解决(民事范畴),什么样的需要公权力介入,如何界定只能根据影响范围来看。阮齐林认为,具体到网络来看,所谓影响范围也就表现为点击率。他说,此前关于传播淫秽物品的司法解释也有类似的规定,比如书传播到多少册就认为是“情节严重”。至于点击率、转发率如何计算,是否可能被“网络水军”钻
Ruan Qilin, Professor of Criminal Law, China University of Political Science and Law and former Vice Chairman of the Criminal Law Research Society of China Law Society: “Explanations on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Criminal Cases of Using Information Networks to Slightlyleft by the Supreme People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate” Reversed 500 Times “Defined ” Plot serious “is the operative clause for the purpose of establishing a conviction. It is a matter of law and technology. It can not say that a post is convicted, and the legal effect of infringing acts is multi-level. It is screened through a standard and what kind of solution belongs to the parties (civil categories) and what The need for public power to intervene, how to define the scope of influence can only be seen. Ruan Qilin believes that specific to the network point of view, the so-called impact range is also reflected in click-through rate. He said that there have been similar provisions on the judicial interpretation of the dissemination of obscene articles, such as how many books spread to the book are considered as ”serious cases.“ As for the click-through rate, how to calculate the forwarding rate, is it possible to ”drill"