“古代中国有无民法”问题 ,学界缠讼已久。相关讨论可一直上溯至杨鸿烈、梅仲协、陈顾远、王伯琦、戴炎辉等老一辈法学家 ,即大致二十世纪三十年代左右。而分歧之线索尚在二十世纪初。古代中国没有民法的说法最早出现于梁启超的《论中国成文法编制之沿革得失》一文。此文成于? “Ancient China has no civil law” problem, the academic community has long been involved in litigation. The relevant discussions can be traced back to the older generation of jurists like Yang Honglie, Mei Zhongkai, Chen Guyuan, Wang Boqi and Dai Yanhui, roughly around the 1930s. The clues are still in the early twentieth century. In ancient China, the argument that there was no civil law first appeared in Liang Qichao’s article “On the Success and Failure of the Development of Chinese Statutory Law.” This article is made?