自徐凤仪《红楼梦偶得》始,清代不同时期的《红楼梦》评点家,纷纷指出《红楼梦》在时序、人物年龄及结局等方面有失照应,他们都承认作者有误,转抄者有责。吴克岐前后以《犬窝谭红》和《庚午老人修改本红楼梦》对《增评补图石头记》进行了两次从回目到字句的细致修改,其关注点和着力处应当受到前人评点的影响。 From Xu Fengyi’s “Dream of Red Mansions”, commenters of “Dream of Red Mansions” in different periods of the Qing Dynasty pointed out that “Dream of Red Mansions” have been found to be irresponsible in timing, character’s age and ending, they all admitted that the author was wrong, . Wu Keqi before and after to “doghouse Tan Hong” and “Gengwu elderly modify this Dream of Red Mansions” to “make up the compilation of stone figure” made twice from the head to the words of the meticulous revisions, the focus and focus should be subject to comment by the predecessors influences.