浅议美国陪审员制度

来源 :China’s foreign Trade·下半月 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:ccyyttaa
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  Abstract : Focusing on the role of the Jury System. The Jury System refers to a kind of important judicial and trial system, which the ordinary citizen is allowed to participate in the judgment of cases, and to exercise judicial power with the professional judge together this ancient legal system comes into two different forms under the influences of varies legal and culture principals in different times and different countries. It is argued that the jury system has its advantages and drawbacks.
  Key words : the Jury System advantages drawbacks
  1.Introduction
  As the result of the development of the ancient assess or system,jury system is also the most important part in the modern system.The main value of the jury system is to protect judicial justice,whose essential is an advanced intension of generaI autonomy in procedure Although it has some weaknesses in eluding wasting time and low-efficiency,even has more biases .
  The American jury consists of a group of ordinary citizen according to facts and evidences presented to them.Trial with the jury is the keystone of theAmerican court system,the study of which is of significance for improving the jury system
  In the United States an accused is entitled to a trial by jury whenever the case is originally brought into federal court and involves an offense for which the punishment may exceed six months imprisonment and in which the defendant is prosecuted as an adult.The jury system originated in England in the Middle Age, magrated to the New World with the first England settlers. And it was elevated to Constitutional stature in two amendments to the Constitution of the United States after the revolution. A grand jury is a group of citizens, usually chosen from the same pool as trial jurors, that is sworn in by a court to hear a case. The grand jury is composed of not less than 12 and not more than 23 persons; and in the Federal courts, the number shall not be less than 16 nor more than 23.
  2.Drawbacks
  As you know,most members of the jury are ordinary people,such as teachers, doctors,cookers and so on,and it's sure that they do not have the legal expertise.That means they will make a decision by their hearts rather than their intellects.And they may miss the truth.
  On the other hands,if the Government cannot protect the jury well , the situation that the jury is being bought off or being threatened will be frequently happen. This will enable the upper social strata to have a good umbrella.And in some states where the number of white people is larger than black people, it will be unfavourable for the black people and it will be unfair in some ways.   3.The advantages of importing the jury system
  First of all, the jury system will increase the independence of the Chinese judicial system The best way to prevent abuse of power is to separate the power; the best way to prevent corruption is to give power to more people.
  Second, the jurors represent the public, which can prevent the public from suspecting that the decision of the case is related to a judge's personal preference. This system will decrease the suspicion of the public that there are any "dirty deals" behind it
  Next, the jury system can educate the public. they can gain the legal knowledge through being a juror. This will also change their traditional view.
  Conclusion:
  As is known to all, there is no perfect system in the world. It is the same with the jury system. We can imagine that even with an appropriate verdict from the jury, a corrupt judge can change it to an inequitable judgment
  However, when we compare doing nothing to pushing for reform, importing the jury system has more significant advantages. However, the jury system will increase the transparency of the trial, and the public will not as often doubt the legality of the judgment.
  Regarding the current circumstances in China, two kinds of methods emerge: The first one is "from the top to the bottom", which means persuading these high level political officers to push this reform. The key to this method is to find a person who has both outstanding political bargaining skills and advanced legal wisdom so that he or she can initiate this tough task。 Another method is "from the bottom to the top", The key to this method is to find a person use Proposal right。
  The purpose of legal system is just to make things clear and make most people feel satisfied.But everything has two different aspects.However,the Jury System makes most of Americans feel protective.Actually,the American Legal System wants to protect the rights of individuals.Thus,it may do harm to the big groups.But those big groups can endure the little loss.That's why the American Legal System thinks the rights of individuals are much important than those big groups.Though,there are a variety of drawbacks in the Jury System.Most importantly,the grand jury stands for the thoughts of most citiziens,and their decisions will contribute to the final result that most of us want to see.But the premise is that they have know the truth of the things before make a decision.And the truth should be found by lawyers and some else.
  References
  [1] Liu Lijun.Study on the Jury System.Hunan:Xiangtan University of Foreign Language Education Press,2008.
  [2] Gao Shan. Research on the Jury System.
  Suzhou:Suzhou University of Foreign Language Education Press,2007.
  [3] A.Arato and P.Breines.The young Lukacs
  and the Origins of Western Marxism.Seabury Press,1979.
  作者簡介:王海鹰,青岛大学法学院 诉讼法学 研究方向:民事诉讼法。
  (作者单位:青岛大学法学院)
其他文献
【摘要】 我國社会在某种程度上,在许多方面,都正处于有法律却无秩序的阶段。社会学家把它称为“失范”,政治学家叫它为“不稳定”,更中性的、遮掩性的说法是“转型时期”。这是一个令世人困惑、法学家们同样困惑的问题。在一些民众看来,在中国搞法治真是太难了。有人干脆说,在中国搞法治,没戏!一些法学家表现出了同样悲观,他们认为,中国制定了那么多的法律,能起到什么作用呢?法治是否适合中国国情呢?中国在法治理念的
期刊
【摘要】 薪酬对于员工和企业都极为重要,也使得薪酬管理变得尤为重要,员工对薪酬是否满意是衡量薪酬管理的一个重要因素。一个令员工满意的薪酬可以大大的留住人才, 激发员工的积极性,进而推动企业实现战略目标。本文围绕薪酬满意度影响因素,从薪酬水平、薪酬结构、薪酬体系、薪酬形式这四个二级等级指标对员工工资薪酬满意度进行了分析和探讨, 并应用AHP 技术对薪酬满意度的影响因素进行量化分析,從而为企业薪酬管理
期刊
Abstract : The research on the supervision of the process of civil lawsuit is a kind of direction which is put forward and taken into consideration in order to adapt the theory and practice. Straighte
期刊
【摘要】 随着经济全球化和世界经济一体化的发展,对外贸易已成为国民经济的重要组成部分,其良好发展对国民经济的增长起着不可忽视的作用。经济发展不仅仅表现为总量的增长,更表现为经济结构的变动,其核心是产业结构的升级调整。本文对黑龙江省对外贸易与产业结构升级进行实证性、相关性分析得出:对外贸易与产业结构升级存在正相关关系。从进口和出口的比较看,出口对各产业的拉动作用要大于进口,说明鼓励出口比促进进口更有
期刊
【摘要】 文章在指出扩大内需是保持国民经济长期、稳定发展动力的基础上,提出了扩大内需应采取的对策及建议。  【关键词】 内需 消费 经济增长 对策  1.扩大内需是保持国民经济长期、稳定发展的动力  判断经济形势的好坏,不仅要看经济增长速度,更要看 影响 经济增长的因素。从拉动我国经济增长的“三驾马车”(投资、消费、进出口贸易)来看,外贸进出口总额2005年已达到1.4万亿美圆,顺差1000
期刊
【摘要】 随着我国石油企业“走出去”战略的深入实施,遇到的诸多问题中国际石油勘探开发合同首当其冲。本文在阐明国际石油勘探开发合同的内容、主要类型及作用的基础上,重点深入分析了在国际市场上影响石油勘探开发合同的经济性因素,为国际石油合作勘探开发项目更好地进行经济评价具有很高的指导意义。  【关键词】 国际石油 勘探开发 合同 经济性  引言  近年来,中国石油企业的国际化水平不断提升。随着国际石油经
期刊
【摘要】 现阶段的信息化建设投资过程呈现出一种过渡、无序和盲目的态势,反映出当前企业间信息技术竞争已陷入典型的“囚徒困境”。本文为解决这一问题,提出加强企业间有效的信息沟通,放眼未来从长远利益出发等策略。  【关键词】 囚徒困境 信息化资本 个人理性 集体理性  信息化资本,是为解决“生产率悖论”应运而生的一种广义经济的新思维,是资本在信息化领域的一种表现形态。它是货币资本投入后,以信息技术为媒介
期刊
【摘要】 财务杠杆在企业的现实经营中具有重要的作用,对财务杠杆的利用效果如何,对企业的兴衰会产生深远的影响。因此,下面就企业财务杠杆利用的相关问题加以探讨。  【关键词】 企业财务杠杆 内涵 作用 注意问题  财务杠杆又称融资杠杆、资本杠杆或者负债经营,是企业在制定资本结构决策时对债务筹资的利用,在利用过程中,只要企业通过适当举债对资本结构加以调整,就有可能给企业带来额外的收益。  1.财务
期刊
为适应我国经济发展需要,我国2006年颁布的新会计准则结合我国实际情况,充分借鉴了国际经验,力求国际会计准则本土化及我国会计准则的国际化。但新准则中,仍存在需要进一步探討的地方,本文就我国无形资产新准则中存在的问题,做出理论性探讨并提出笔者建议。  1.无形资产新准则中存在的问题  1.1无形资产确认的范围  1.1.1新准则中无形资产确认的范围  新准则规定,无形资产通常包括专利权、非专利技术、
期刊
【摘要】 财务管理历来都是事业单位管理的重点之一,科学有效的财务管理对于事业单位的发展来说意义重大。本文就从事业单位的财务管理问题出发,对于其中存在的问题进行总结和分析,进而结合财务管理规范的要求和实际运行中的新问题进行分析和探讨,提出有效的对策和建议。  【关键词】 行政事业单位 财务管理 创新思路 分析  财务管理中很容易忽视掉的就是这优化的过程。在有限的筹资渠道中,根据现有的渠道和条件
期刊